The Honda Pilot has long been recognized as a highly sought-after midsize SUV, particularly among those seeking a versatile and family-oriented vehicle.
With its three rows of seating, generous storage capacity, and innovative features, it has consistently appealed to a wide range of buyers.
However, the introduction of the new generation Pilot in 2023 has brought about a host of exciting changes.
Boasting a fresh and modern styling, increased interior space, and the addition of a TrailSport version with enhanced off-roading capabilities, the latest iteration of the Pilot aims to further solidify its position as a top contender in its class.
Nevertheless, astute consumers are aware that the Pilot is not the sole option available in the midsize SUV market. Toyota, Honda’s long-standing rival, has recently unveiled its own contender in the form of the all-new Grand Highlander.
As its name suggests, the Toyota Grand Highlander surpasses the regular Highlander in terms of size and spaciousness.
Furthermore, it incorporates a number of upgrades that make it a formidable competitor to the Pilot.
With both models vying for the title of the best three-row SUV, the experts at Edmunds have taken it upon themselves to conduct a comprehensive comparison, meticulously analyzing and evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of each vehicle to determine which one ultimately emerges as the superior choice.
FUEL ECONOMY AND POWER
The Honda Pilot is equipped with a robust V6 engine that boasts an impressive 285 horsepower, ensuring a powerful and dynamic driving experience.
This level of performance allows the Pilot to effortlessly navigate various terrains and handle demanding driving situations with ease.
Additionally, the Pilot offers a commendable fuel economy, with an estimated range of 20-22 miles per gallon in combined city and highway driving, as determined by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
This level of efficiency is particularly noteworthy for a midsize three-row SUV, as it strikes a balance between power and economy.
Overall, the Honda Pilot’s combination of a potent V6 engine and respectable fuel efficiency makes it a compelling choice for those seeking a versatile and capable vehicle in the midsize SUV segment.
The majority of Grand Highlander buyers will ultimately opt for the vehicle’s turbocharged four-cylinder engine, which boasts an impressive 265 horsepower.
In terms of fuel efficiency, the Grand Highlander also outperforms the Pilot, with EPA estimates ranging from 22 to 24 mpg combined.
Toyota takes it a step further by providing two hybrid powertrain options for the Grand Highlander. The first is the regular Grand Highlander Hybrid, which may be slightly underpowered at 245 horsepower but compensates with an impressive EPA estimate of up to 36 mpg combined.
Additionally, there is a Hybrid Max version available, which offers a substantial increase in power at 362 horsepower while still maintaining a respectable fuel efficiency of 27 mpg.
When comparing the Pilot’s V6 engine to the Grand Highlander’s offerings, it is clear that Toyota provides a wider range of economical options and greater variety.
This is a significant advantage for consumers seeking a vehicle that not only meets their expectations but also offers enhanced fuel efficiency. Therefore, the Grand Highlander emerges as the clear winner in this regard.
INTERIOR AND TECHNOLOGY
When it comes to family-oriented SUVs, storage is a crucial feature that cannot be overlooked. In this regard, Toyota has gone above and beyond with the Grand Highlander.
With a generous 20.6 cubic feet of storage space behind its third row, the Grand Highlander outdoes its Honda counterpart, which offers only 18.6 cubic feet.
The Grand Highlander’s advantage only grows when you fold down the second- or third-row seats, providing ample space for all your cargo needs.
Additionally, the third-row seating area in the Grand Highlander is more comfortable for adults than that of the Honda.
But Toyota’s excellence in the Grand Highlander doesn’t stop at storage. The SUV also boasts impressive tech features that put it ahead of the competition.
The standard 12.3-inch center touchscreen is both responsive and visually stunning, making it a pleasure to use.
In comparison, the Honda Pilot’s base 7-inch screen pales in comparison. While a larger 9-inch screen is available for the Pilot, it still falls short of the Grand Highlander’s standard offering.
Both SUVs offer standard driver assist features such as traffic-adaptive cruise control and lane keeping assistance systems, but the Grand Highlander goes the extra mile with additional features such as a low-speed hands-free driving mode in congested traffic situations.
Overall, the Grand Highlander emerges as the clear winner in the family-oriented SUV category. With its superior storage capacity, comfortable seating, and advanced tech features, it is the ideal choice for families seeking a reliable and versatile SUV.
DRIVING AND COMFORT
The Grand Highlander is an exceptionally user-friendly vehicle, boasting a driving experience that is both effortless and enjoyable.
Its smooth ride quality ensures a comfortable journey, even when encountering larger bumps on the road.
While the acceleration of the base Grand Highlander and Highlander Hybrid models is perfectly suitable for city driving, it may feel slightly lacking in power when attempting to overtake on the highway or when carrying a full complement of passengers.
Despite this minor drawback, the Grand Highlander remains a highly capable and refined vehicle, offering a level of ease and comfort that is sure to impress even the most discerning drivers.
PRICING AND VALUE
Honda has recently launched its 2024 Pilot lineup, which comprises three different trim levels catering to different budgets and needs.
The base LX trim is priced at $38,465, including the destination fee, and offers a decent set of features.
However, if you’re looking for more luxurious features, you’ll have to upgrade to the $43,775 EX-L trim, which includes leather upholstery, a power rear liftgate, and a larger 9-inch center touchscreen.
The Elite trim level, which is the top-of-the-line model, is priced at $53,855 and offers the most advanced features.
On the other hand, the Grand Highlander, Toyota’s latest offering in the SUV segment, starts at a higher price point of $44,465 for the XLE trim.
However, the features offered in this trim level are comparable to those of the Pilot’s EX-L trim. Additionally, some desirable features, such as ventilated front seats, are available for a lower price on the Grand Highlander than on the Pilot.
The top-of-the-line Platinum trim is priced at $54,940, and hybrid versions are available for a few thousand dollars more, which can help save money on gas in the long run.
Overall, both the Honda Pilot and the Toyota Grand Highlander offer a range of features and capabilities that cater to different needs and budgets.
While the Pilot offers a lower starting price, the Grand Highlander offers more advanced features at a slightly higher price point. Ultimately, the choice between these two SUVs will depend on your specific requirements and preferences.
EDMUNDS SAYS
When it comes to choosing a family SUV, there are many factors to consider. The venerable Pilot has long been a popular choice, and for good reason. Its appealing utility and driving satisfaction make it a reliable and enjoyable vehicle to own.
However, when compared to the Grand Highlander, it becomes clear that the latter offers a more impressive package in terms of value, technology, and passenger comfort.
The Grand Highlander goes above and beyond in these areas, making it our top pick for the superior family SUV.
One of the key advantages of the Grand Highlander is its exceptional value. With its competitive pricing and extensive list of standard features, it offers a lot of bang for your buck.
Whether you’re looking for advanced safety features, convenient technology, or luxurious touches, the Grand Highlander has it all.
It provides a level of sophistication and refinement that is hard to match in its class, and at a price point that is surprisingly affordable.
In terms of technology, the Grand Highlander truly stands out. Its advanced infotainment system is intuitive and user-friendly, providing seamless connectivity and access to a wide range of entertainment options.
The inclusion of features such as a wireless charging pad, a head-up display, and a surround-view camera system further enhance the overall driving experience.
With the Grand Highlander, you’ll never feel behind the times when it comes to technology.
Passenger comfort is another area where the Grand Highlander excels. The spacious and well-designed interior provides ample room for both passengers and cargo, making it ideal for family trips or daily commutes.
The seats are plush and supportive, ensuring that everyone can relax and enjoy the ride. Additionally, the Grand Highlander offers a smooth and quiet driving experience, further enhancing passenger comfort and making long journeys a breeze.
In conclusion, while the venerable Pilot certainly has its merits, the Grand Highlander surpasses it in terms of value, technology, and passenger comfort.
With its exceptional value, advanced technology features, and luxurious interior, the Grand Highlander is the clear winner in the family SUV category.
If you’re in the market for a reliable and enjoyable vehicle that offers the best in terms of overall package, the Grand Highlander is the superior choice.